Hi, all. This is my first post, but I decided to join because I've been an HP slueth for about a while now. I got the first mysteries book almost as soon as it came out, same with the 'new clues' addition. I was so excited about it that I began analyzing the 5th book like a fiend...it's covered with pink post-it notes. My parents think I'm insane, as do most of my friends, but it's good to know that there are others like me out there!
I have a few theories about the septology...and I have opinions about the theories presented in the books, and I'm so excited about discussing them here.
My first comment: I completely disagree with the James/Remus theory. This may just be because I've had this odd dislike for James ever since the fifth book...and because I LOVE REMUS with every fiber of my mis-guided being. I do think that it's well supported, but I also think it's quite a long stretch.